- 1 February 2023
Pipe Relining vs Pipe Replacement: Which is the Better Option?
When it comes to fixing damaged pipes, there are two main options: pipe relining and pipe replacement. Both of these methods can be effective, but they each have their pros and cons. So in this article, we'll take a closer look at each method to help you decide which one is the better option for your situation.
What is Pipe Relining?
Pipe relining is a process that involves repairing damaged pipes from the inside out. The process begins with a thorough inspection of the pipes to determine the extent of the damage. Once the damage has been identified, the pipes are cleaned to remove any debris or buildup.
The next step involves lining the pipes with a resin material. The resin is applied to the inside of the pipes and cured, essentially creating a new pipe within the old one. The result is a seamless, jointless pipe that is highly resistant to leaks and other forms of damage.
The materials used for pipe relining can vary depending on the specific situation. However, in general, the materials used are highly durable and long-lasting, ensuring that the repaired pipes will last for many years to come.
What is Pipe Replacement?
Pipe replacement is a method of fixing damaged pipes that involves removing the damaged section of the pipe and replacing it with a new one.
The pipe replacement process begins with an inspection of the pipes to determine the extent of the damage. Once the damage has been identified, the old pipes are removed and replaced with new ones.
Pipe replacement provides a permanent solution to damaged pipes, as there is no risk of further damage to the pipes in the future. New pipes are less likely to clog or become damaged, ensuring that water supply and drainage are working properly.
Pros and Cons of Pipe Relining and Pipe Replacement
When it comes to choosing between pipe relining and pipe replacement, there are pros and cons to consider. Pipe relining is a less expensive and less invasive option, but it may not be suitable for all situations. Pipe replacement is a more permanent solution but can be more expensive and time-consuming.
Cost considerations are an important factor to consider when choosing between pipe relining and pipe replacement. Pipe relining is generally less expensive than pipe replacement, but it may not be a permanent solution. Pipe replacement, on the other hand, provides a permanent solution but can be more expensive.
In addition, the specific situation and the type of pipes involved are important factors to consider when choosing between pipe relining and pipe replacement. A professional plumber can evaluate the situation and recommend the best course of action.
The Comparison of Cost Between Pipe Replacement and Pipe Relining
The cost of pipe replacement and pipe relining varies greatly and is dependent on various factors. There is no standard price for either service.
The cost of pipe relining depends on the specific situation. Although pipe relining can appear expensive compared to traditional pipe replacement, it ultimately comes out as the more cost-effective option when considering the added expenses of installing a new driveway, the inconvenience of excavation, and the time required.
Pipe replacement is typically more expensive than pipe relining. Since the entire pipe needs to be replaced, the cost of materials and labour is often higher with pipe replacement.
It's important to note that each job is unique, and the cost can vary significantly depending on the site or equipment required. Therefore, we highly recommend consulting a professional to receive an accurate free quote.
The Comparison of Time Required for Pipe Replacement and Pipe Relining
Repairing a buried or obstructed pipe through excavation can be a time-consuming process. It can take days or even weeks to complete, and if you need to rebuild and re-landscape the area, it can take months to restore it to its original condition. Therefore, it's important to consider the long-term impact this can have on your daily life.
In contrast, pipe relining or patching may only take a day. This method is much faster than pipe replacement. The time spent digging the soil, removing the old pipes, and replacing them is eliminated with pipe relining. In fact, a pipe can be fixed within two hours using this method.
Since there is almost no digging involved, traffic around the area of the repairs is not affected. This is particularly beneficial for commercial premises that require pipe repair to be done. Furthermore, pipe relining is a quiet process, which means it can be carried out at any time, day or night.
The Comparison of Durability Between Pipe Replacement and Pipe Relining
Although it may be tempting to assume that relining, being a second pipe within a damaged pipe, would be less resilient than installing new pipes, this assumption is incorrect. In reality, relined pipes can be more durable than new pipes.
In many cases, pipe relining offers a longer-term solution than pipe replacement. Pipe relining often comes with warranties ranging from 10 to 25 years, which gives a good indication of their effectiveness.
Correctly installed pipe relining work has a life expectancy of 50 to 100 years, which doubles the lifespan of the pipeline that was already in place. Although most warranties cover 25 years, the lining can last even longer, up to around a hundred years. This highlights the durability and effectiveness of pipe relining as a long-lasting solution for damaged pipes.
When is Pipe Relining the Better Option?
One of the main advantages of pipe relining is that it can be used to repair pipes without causing major disruptions to a property's infrastructure. In situations where digging up the existing pipes would be too costly or disruptive, pipe relining offers a cost-effective and non-invasive solution.
In addition, pipe relining is a good option for buildings with historic or unique architecture, where digging up the existing pipes may not be feasible.
When is Pipe Replacement the Better Option?
Not all types of pipes can be relined. Pipes that are severely damaged or have significant structural issues may not be suitable for relining. In addition, pipes that are too small or too large may not be suitable for relining.
Pipe replacement is a better option when the pipes' damage is severe or when the existing pipes are beyond repair. It is also a good option when the pipes need to be resized or when the existing pipes are not up to code.
What is the The Best Method to Repair Your Pipe?
Replacing damaged piping is the traditional method, but that doesn't necessarily make it the best option. This approach involves digging a large trench on your property to access the damaged pipe, which can be time-consuming, costly, and damaging to your landscaping.
In contrast, pipe relining is a more efficient and effective method that strengthens the pipe overall. Instead of repairing the pipe from the outside, relining creates a new seal on the inside using a resin that hardens into a new pipe-within-a-pipe.
This eliminates the need to dig a trench, saving you the hassle of restoring your landscaping after the repairs. Pipe relining is also ideal for hard-to-reach pipes, such as those in the walls of your home or under the foundation.
For these reasons, pipe relining is widely considered the best method to repair your pipes. It is more cost-effective, less invasive, and can provide a long-lasting solution to damaged pipes.
FAQs
In conclusion, both pipe relining and pipe replacement are effective methods for fixing damaged pipes. The better option depends on the specific situation, the type of pipes involved, and the budget available. By consulting with a professional plumber and taking into consideration the factors discussed in this article, you can make an informed decision that will ensure a long-lasting and effective solution to your damaged pipes.
At P24 Pipe Relining Sydney, we provide professional plumbing services that help our clients choose the most effective and efficient solution for their plumbing problems. Contact us today to learn more about our services and how we can help you with your plumbing needs.
TAGS:
Pipe Relining